Gentle Souls Heels
"O Gee" in Penny
$60 via Overstock.com (bought back in July)
Comfort: B, I am still a little unsure about the comfort of these shoes. They feel like a sneaker they are so comfortable but they rub my little toe so I cannot wear them all day. Also, the day after I wear this pair of shoes my feet hurt no matter what I wear (unless I wear this pair again). I know this sounds weird but this is my most comfortable yet most uncomfortable pair of shoes.
Cost: B+, There were $60 at Overstock.com (the normal retail is $235). This is the most expensive pair of shoes that I own, but comfort shoes are expensive (and should be worth every penny in the long run). I spent months stalking pairs on ebay and this is the best price I found.
Looks: B-, I Love the color! Originally I wanted black, but this color was on sale so I went with this silvery color and I love it. It is a neutral but has more of a pop than black does. The shoes are a little chunky for my taste, but not too bad. They look best with slacks but look fine with skirts. I don't see them as fun shoes or going out shoes but they are perfect for work.
Wearability: B, I have worn these shoes to work many times. They look nice with slacks (here, here, here, and here too) and dresses (here and here too). I am sure they would look nice with jeans and skirts too. I wouldn't wear them out (not that I go "out") but they are perfect work shoes.
Overall: B, Good shoes! I would buy them again! I thought I would be singing praise about this pair of shoes - but I am not (at least not yet). They are not bad but they are not wonderful either. I would like to try the flats to see if there is a difference but there are so many brands to try I will probably wait a while.
Have you tried Gentle Souls shoes?